The Dare Game

This is a story that started out as one thing, and slowly became another as I wrote it. I'm not sure what genre it would even fit in, or if this sort of thing is interesting to others. So I'm putting it up on my blog for free, and I am open to feedback as to what comes next, if anything. 

Anyway, enjoy!

The Dare Game by Lou Bealy

Support my writing by becoming a subscriber on Subscribestar!

Get access to exclusive content and benefits!

    Nick and Melanie entered “Love-Lee’s”, the strange sex shop that had seemed to pop up out of nowhere some time in the last few days. No one seemed to know who owned it and when it had been built, but it was the talk of all the ladies at Melanie’s office. This new place supposedly had some high tech equipment that none of the girls had ever seen before. She was told that she “had” to see it, and maybe pick up one of those unique sex toys, or “marital aids” as Nick would call them.

Nick had always been something of a vanilla prude. Over the 4 years of marriage and 3 years of dating before that, she had tried multiple times to get him to try some more adventurous things in the bedroom, but he had always balked at the idea.

When Melanie was told just how amazing this new sex shop was, she decided to play a little trick on him. She bought some movie tickets for the theater nearby, and parked the car so they would have to walk past.

After the cheesy horror movie, they held hands strolled down the street towards the car. She always felt safe with him, She couldn’t necessarily rely on him to provide an exciting sex life, she knew that, but she knew he would do anything to protect her. His tall stature and wide frame always inspired people to give them a wide berth. He had always been a natural athlete. He hadn’t played football since college, but he still kept himself in great shape. He had given up the battle with hair loss and shaved his head, which she said made him look even sexier. His dark eyes had a soft quality to them, one you might not expect of someone so physically imposing. He was a big teddy bear, despite his somewhat intimidating countenance.

By contrast, she was short and petite. She had dark hair and a cute, freckled face with a small button nose. Not what you would call imposing at all. She made up for it with her fierce, stubborn personality.

    As they passed the shop, she steered him inside. He protested for a moment, but when she left his side to disappear into the strange building, he had no choice but to follow.

    It was not like any sex shop she had ever seen. She knew that Nick had never been in one so he had no basis of comparison, but even he was pretty shocked.

    There were men and women in various stages of undress all around. None were actually naked, but some were pretty close, wearing only a skin tight leotard or just assless chaps and a thong. They seemed to be employees, or people demoing the merchandise. There were strange body suits lining the walls, looking like men and women of various body types. A few of the employees were wearing these strange suits, like a man wearing a suit that made him look like a woman in a string bikini, or a woman wearing a suit that made her look like an anthropomorphic squirrel. It was absolutely surreal. Nick was speechless, just gawking at the various displays of raw eroticism all around him.

    Melanie kept pulling him along with her. They made their way into the main sales area, where a few dozen people were wearing gloves and headsets while seemingly plugged into some kind of virtual reality. They were all gyrating obscenely and moaning obscenities. There were many other monitors showing various pornographic videos of all different genres.

    Melanie noticed an area that seemed devoted to naughty games. There were board games, video games, card games, and the like stacked on shelves that reached the ceiling. She noticed a bright red box that said “The Dare Game” on it in white lettering.

    “This looks fun, what do you think?” she said, handing the box over her shoulder to Nick.

He took it from her and began scrutinizing it immediately. “Hm, it just says ‘the sexy game of pushing boundaries and transforming your understanding of yourself through new experiences. Limitless randomly generated dares.’” he sighed. “Whew, that is a mouthful.”

    “Sounds like fun.” she said, with a hint of pleading in her voice.

“What kind of new experiences?” asked Nick as he looked over the box.

    “I don’t know, new ones. Surprising ones. That’s the point, isn’t it?” replied Melanie in a teasing tone.

    “I don’t know. I’m not really into any of this stuff. I don’t need help getting off, or getting you off.” He said dismissively. He handed her back the game box.

    She frowned at him, pouting. “You never do anything new or spontaneous with me! You said we would go on adventures!”

    “This is just a board game, not an adventure.” He said, knowing that he was losing and that she was right.”

    “Exactly! If you won’t even try a new game with me, then when will we ever go on these supposed adventures? It’s only fifty bucks. C’mon. Please?” she batted her eyes at him.

    He sighed and looked over the box again.

    ***

    When they go home, she tore the box open. Inside was a small tablet computer with a touch screen. It also appeared to have a small camera above the screen. They powered it up immediately without looking at the instructions.

There was a little intro where the words “Dare Game” scrolled across the screen. Then they were prompted with a screen that asked for the names of the players.

    “Asshole.” Nick typed in, chuckling. The a little blue light blinked next to the camera, and then a virtual version of him was displayed on screen, with the word “Asshole” displayed next to it.

“Mel.” Melanie giggled as she punched it in. She wanted to hurry up and get to the fun. Her own avatar appeared next to the name Mel.

Then they were each asked if they had played before, and they both answered no.

The screen displayed the two of them on a virtual landscape that seemed to recreate the house. Between them was a giant arrow. It lay in the center of the screen.

“Whoa” said Nick, surprised at the detail.

Then the screen brightly displayed a message in old computer green. “Spin to see who goes first. Someone new can join in any time by spinning.” A robotic voice repeated the message every so often. There was a button displayed over the arrow that said “Spin”.

“Okay. It says that we can play with two or more people. But it recommends more.” Nick said, reading the box. “I’m saying right now, I’m not playing with anyone else.” Then he smiled. “Unless you get some cute girls here...” he teased.

    Melanie got serious, her eyes narrowed. “And you thought I would bring some other guy into the game? Getting jealous already? No, no one else is going to play.” she said as she stood up. “I’m going to grab a drink, you want one?” she left for the kitchen.

    Nick reached for the instructions. “There are three kinds of dares!” he yelled to her in the other room. “Chosen, random, and all!”

    He continued to read the instructions to her as she grabbed the drinks. With “chosen” dares, the person who had spun got to pick the person and whatever dare they wanted, including random. Random dares were generated to a random person, besides the one had had spun. Then the “All” dare would affect everyone with a random dare. The machine would generate random dares, and be the ultimate arbiter for interpreting vague dares.

    “How do you win?” she shouted back, now in their bedroom.

    “Does it matter? You aren’t winning!” he laughed

She popped her head back in the room a second. “Oh, really?” she said, smiling. “You of all people are going to win a dare game? You wanna bet on that?” she chuckled.

“Bet what?” he said skeptically.

“What does it matter, if you are going to win?” she teased. “Let’s just say I get another dare that you can’t refuse?” she grinned evilly.

“And same for me, if I win?” he asked, and she nodded.

“Alright then!” he said, summoning some confidence. He was sure he could handle whatever she threw at him.

Melanie turned back to grab drinks and Nick looked at the instructions. “Uhh… you each start with one credit. You lose a credit if you refuse to perform a dare. This is kinda complicated…” he complained.

    “The machine does all the work, it seems!” she yelled back.

He ignored her and continued. “And the first person to perform each dare-all gets a credit. Some dares have time limits as imposed by the machine, and you can lose a credit if you don’t perform a dare in the time limit. Some dares are open ended, where you have to continue performing them or you lose a credit. If you would lose a credit and have none, then you are eliminated. I guess it just goes on until there is one person left.” He finished.

    Nick was starting to think Melanie had been gone for awhile when she came back in plain white t-shirt and panties. Nick always thought she looked sexy in anything, though. She didn’t need fancy clothes or makeup. She was the ideal woman to him. She had two screwdrivers and she handed him one.

    She plopped down next to him on the couch and sipped her drink. “You didn’t spin yet?” she asked, noticing the same message displayed on the screen.

    “I, no.” Nick said awkwardly, taking a big drink so he didn’t have to talk.

    “Look, I know you don’t want to do this, but just play a little, and I’m sure it’ll get the juices flowing, and we can...you know.” She smiled, trying to get him to relax.

    “Alright.” Nick said, hitting the virtual spinner on the touch screen. He got a 1. Figures, he thought.

    “Oh, sorry honey.” she said, rubbing his leg before leaning forward to hit the spinner. She got a 4. “I go first!” she said, excited and giggling.

    “We knew you would.” said Nick, a little annoyed.

    “I know, this is just fun, okay? I’m glad you are playing with me.” she smiled, and gave him a kiss.

    “Spin again” the machine said.

    “Oh! Right.” she said, hitting the spinner again. It landed on Dare-All. “Oh, here we go!” she said, smiling. “What are we supposed to do?”

    “Just watch.” he said, shaking his head.

    The Dare-All message flickered and was then replaced with a screen.

    “Ha!” he said, pointing at her. “You get it too.”

    “You suck.” She stuck her tongue out.

    “I’m going to dare you to suck!” he said, poking her in the side. She poked him back and they started a tickle fight.

    They were interrupted by the robot voice. “Beginners: Asshole and Mel, are let off easy. The random dare is: to strip down to your underwear.”

“I didn’t realize it had an attitude as well.” said Nick before turning to Melanie. “Strip. That’s kind of funny.” he pointed at her t-shirt and panties.

“I know, it’s more of a party game, I guess.” Melanie replied, frowning. She pulled her t-shirt off, showing her plain white bra underneath, containing her perfect sized c-cup breasts.

Then the robot voice started counting down, and corresponding numerals were flashing brightly on the screen. Nick quickly started to take his clothes off, but he was way more dressed up than she was at this point. He unfastened his buttons on his shirt as quickly as he could before unbuckling his belt and just dropping his pants, jumping out of them. He whipped his shirt off and the flopped onto his back to remove his socks with a few seconds to spare. He stood back up in nothing but his navy blue boxer shorts.

“I get the credit.” she laughed as he was visibly trying to calm down and relax after the sudden urgency and exertion.

“No, it says I do.” he said, pointing at the screen.

“What?” she said turning to look at the screen. It confirmed what he said, and she immediately realized her mistake. Her avatar was still wearing socks too, and they flashed an angry red until she removed them. She had now actually removed her socks, but it was too late. She lost her credit. Now she was at zero. “I guess I have to do whatever you tell me to do, now.” she said, seductively.

“Yes you will. You’re losing for sure… hey! Why do you get to spin again?!” asked Nick, feeling cheated when he saw the computer prompt her to spin again.

“I guess it’s because it was a dare-all.” she replied in a teasing voice. “Or maybe it was because I failed."

“Yea, it’s because it was a dare-all.” Nick said, looking at the rules again. “So spin already.” he said, giving her attitude right back.

She reached up and hit the button. She noticed that her virtual avatar was now bare chested, and Nick’s was in his underwear. The virtual wheel spun and landed on dare choice.

“So I can pick. Let’s see…” she said contemplating what to make him do. She sat for a moment, letting him anticipate what she was going to make him do.

“Don’t think too hard about it,” said Nick, reading his wife’s face. “I can still refuse to do it.” He laughed and gestured to the one credit he had next to his name.

“Shut up! I’m thinking!” she laughed. After a few moments, she finally said “You should do what I can hardly ever get you to do. Go down on me and satisfy me.” She grinned as she lowered her panties, revealing her shaved snatch that was already a little wet at the excitement. “And don’t refuse this one, or you’ll never get a blowjob again!” she said, pointing at his remaining credit. “You were saying you were going to dare me to blow you!” she teased.

“And now I definitely will.” he replied matter-of-factly.

The computer chimed in with “you have 10 minutes to make her cum, starting… now.”

“Ten minutes?!” Nick huffed. The computer evidently set the particular rules.

“You better get on it, then.” Melanie giggled, wiggling her legs and continuing to display her horny wet pussy.

Nick sighed. He figured this was coming. It wasn’t a big deal for him to go down on her, he just preferred to skip all the preamble and get to the good stuff, the fucking. But she always wanted him to slow it down. “Here,” he gestured to the padded ottoman in front of the couch.

She lay with the center of her back on the ottoman and her legs splayed out. He grabbed each leg and placed it on his shoulders. He leaned in and started kissing her clit. She moaned in response to his soft lips and tongue caressing her sensitive little nub.

He was tempted to go really fast, because of the time limit, but he knew how to get her to cum. He was going to do it right. He licked around her opening, before spreading her inner labia apart and inserting the tip of his tongue.

“That’s it…” she sighed, grabbing one of the couch pillows and squeezing it. She buried her face in the pillow and cried out as his tongue penetrated slightly deeper. She loved when he did that.

After a few moments of sliding his tongue in her opening, he went back to attacking her clit. He licked and sucked on it, knowing that she must be close.

“Oh, it’s right there, yeah. Oh yeah.” she babbled as she grabbed his head and forced it into her crotch. She felt her orgasm approaching.

He sucked the now engorged nub into his mouth and licked it rapidly with the tip of his tongue. That was enough to push her over the edge.

“Fuck...yes…” she cried out as she dropped the pillow. The orgasm hit her suddenly. After the initial wave, her body tingled pleasure from her toes to her tits for another minute or so. She gasped for air as she stood back up. His face was dripping with girl cum and he had a big grin on his face. It had only taken him 3 minutes.

He turned to the computer, which was now telling him to spin.

“Finally.” he muttered as he got to the machine, he hit the spin button and watched it come up random.”

“Aww…” he said. “This better be good. A least better than telling you to strip when you are already mostly there anyway.”

“Oh, hush. I lost a credit on that. Stupid socks.” Melanie replied.

“Mel’s random dare, stick this butt plug in your ass and leave it there, unless biologically required to remove it. Remember to use plenty of lube when first attempting penetration of the anus.” said the robotic voice.

“That last part sounded like a PSA.” laughed Nick.

The letters scrolled across the screen. Above the letters was the picture of a small pink butt plug, sitting next to the game box on the table. It was one of those conical deals, with the little flat handle. They both turned to look at the table at same time, equally confused.

“Holy shit. How did I not notice that? Did it fall out of the box?” said Nick as he picked up the heretofore unnoticed butt plug, amazed he it had evaded both of their attention until now.

“Yeah, it must have, I didn’t see it either.” she scowled at it. I’m supposed to put it in my ass? I don’t know where it has been!” she complained. “And I have no lube!” she yelled at the screen.

“Sucks to be you, I don’t make the rules.” teased Nick and then they heard the familiar beep. “And now you are running out of time.”

“Oh, wow.” said Melanie, shocked. She stared at the plug for a moment, as the clock ticked down. On a hunch, she reached into the box and found what she was looking for.

“We missed that too?” asked Nick, amazed.

“I know right? But I figured it would be there, since this plug was.” she said, proud of her quick thinking.

Brian watched her pour lube from the bottle she found into her hand. She slathered a generous amount on the plug before putting turning around to bend over slightly. In her still horny state, she was actually kind of excited to try it.

The pointed tip found her hole. She sighed and tried to relax as she slipped it inside. Besides the little bit of pain, there was also the novel feeling of being penetrated there for the first time. It only stretched painfully a little bit. Thankfully, it was a pretty small butt plug, she thought. It slipped all the way in, so that just the handle was sticking out.

“So how long do I have to keep this in here?” she wondered out loud. She took a few deep breaths, getting used to its presence.

“I guess until the end of the game?” he looked at the instructions, unsure. “Or until I dare you to take it out so my dick can go in.” He grinned

“Oooo… well then we’ll just have to see, won’t we?” she smiled back. She sat back down gingerly. “I guess it’s my turn.” she hit the spin button, and it came up Dare-Random.

“Let’s see what fun thing that the robot is going to tell me to do.” said Nick sarcastically.

“Beginner Asshole: your random dare is as follows.” There was a pause. “You have 15 minutes to suck a cock.”

Nick nearly spat out his drink. “What?!” He stood up, and saw the words begin to scroll across the screen.

Melanie laughed. “Hey, the machine came up with it.”

The robot voice continued. “You must suck it for at least 3 minutes.” The display shifted to what looked like a map, with red dots spread out across it.

Nick seethed for a moment before saying “No fucking way.”

The machine seemed to immediately recognize his refusal to perform the dare. The countdown stopped, and he lost a credit. He had one more, since he had won the credit from doing the random dare first.

“I don’t know how I was supposed to do that anyway. There are only two players, and you don’t have a cock.” Nick said, frustrated.

Melanie laughed again. “I think you were just supposed to find one. Maybe on that map.” she teased. “Serves you right for suggesting bringing some ladies. That was perfect.”

“My turn.” he slapped the screen to spin, clearly annoyed.

“Relax, babe.” said Melanie, stroking his thigh. She gasped as she was reminded of the plug in her ass. She had shifted her weight just so to push the plug a little deeper.

“What was that? Enjoying yourself, are you?” he asked, poking her side.

“Stop…” she deflected his hand away. “It’s not a bad feeling.” she said, trying to find a comfortable position to sit. She didn’t want to mention how she almost liked the stretching feeling. It was a feeling she was familiar with, but there was the added novelty because it was in a “naughtier” place.

“Oh, come on, you don’t like it at all?” he continued to tease. He tried to grab her shoulders to force her down in her seat but she darted away. She hit the spin button as she moved past the machine. It came up choice.

“Ha.” she exclaimed, sticking her tongue out at him. “I dare you to put a butt plug in your ass, and I dare you to like it.” she giggled.

“I’m not sure that’s how it works.” he laughed.

They both turned to the screen, wondering how it would interpret that dare. Again, it showed a pink butt plug, this time slightly larger, for some reason, on the table. They both looked and sure enough, there again was a butt plug there, apparently having fallen out of the box like the last one.

“How did we miss two butt plugs falling out of the box?” wondered Nick. This was getting a little strange.

“I dunno, we dumped it out pretty quick.” replied Melanie, who was now searching the table and box for any other surprises. She didn’t find anything. She turned to Nick. “You better get it in there.” she laughed, pointing at the screen.

He turned to look, and sure enough, the clock was counting down, in an identical scenario to Melanie’s, except the slightly larger plug. He grabbed the large plug. “Why couldn’t you get the bigger one? And does it have to be pink?” he complained. He yanked his shorts down. Then he dumped a generous amount of lube on his hand and applied it to his ass. Then did the same with the plug.

“It highlighted which dildo to use.” she reminded him. “And you’d be happier with what, a black butt plug in your ass?” she laughed.

“Very funny.” he said, as he bent over, hastily shoving the plug in his ass to try and beat the clock, which he did by several seconds. It didn’t actually hurt that bad, really. He was surprised. As he got used to its presence, and he rocked back and forth on the couch to force it a little deeper, he had to admit it was feeling kind of good.

Melanie seemed to notice. She laughed and pointed at his face. “You are liking it, aren’t you?” she giggled.

He blushed, not knowing what to say. He couldn’t deny it. He just reached out to hit the spin button. It came up dare-choice. “About time.” he said happily.

“So what are you going to make me do?” she grinned. “You know I can’t say no, or I will lose. And I’m not losing.” she crossed her arms.

Nick had a moment of thought, and decided to test a theory. “Is that so? I already know how to make you give up. You gave it away earlier.” he grinned right back at her.

“Oh? And what was that?” she replied, laughing. This was getting good.

“I dare you to let me include another woman in the game.” he shouted triumphantly. “And like it!” he added.

The screen displayed scrolling text of the dare. “If another player has not joined in twenty-four hours, Mel loses a point and the game.” Said the robot voice.

“I knew it!” she laughed, poking his side. He jumped off the couch to get away. “Who? Who are you getting to join?” She was visibly rocking back and forth, working the plug in her ass. The excitement was clear on her face. She didn’t react with the anger or disdain that he expected.

Is it possible? Nick thought. He looked at the machine skeptically. Can it make her like it? He thought about the fact that she had dared him to enjoy the butt plug.

After a moment, he shook his head. That was impossible. A computer can’t alter your mind any more than it can conjure butt plugs from the aether, he thought.

“Asshole did not specify who.” the electronic voice seemed to reply to them. “As long as another player joins in the time limit, the game will continue.”

The two of them made eye contact. Then they burst out laughing as they each rushed to grab their phone. The race was on.

Not sure what exactly comes next. Tell me in the comments who you think gets someone else to join before the other. Tell me what you think the computer could do to them.

Support my writing by becoming a subscriber on Subscribestar!

Get access to exclusive content and benefits!

Have an idea for a story that you would love to have fleshed out? Check out my custom stories page!